Ilhan Omar exposed

 1. About 9/11, Ilhan Omar said "Some people did something" :

"Some people did something" is how Ilhan Omar described the events of 9/11, while talking about discrimination faced by Muslims in the US post 9/11. There is no excuse whatsoever for this flippant, insensitive and dismissive way of characterizing a national tragedy. She should have called it what it was—a terrorist attack that killed around 3000 people. No Ilhan Omar, it was not some people doing something. That is minimizing it and hurting a lot of people. I've seen articles trying to justify this remark. This is utter and complete disingenuousness.

Yes, there was discrimination faced by many Muslims in US after 9/11, but that in no way justifies Ilhan Omar's remark.

https://www.businessinsider.in/11-victim-who-criticized-her-in-his-speech-at-ground-zero/articleshow/71140951.cms

Ilhan didn't even bother to apologize for her remarks.

No words of apology in either of these 2 interviews and I couldn't find any instance where she did actually apologize.

https://twitter.com/FaceTheNation/status/1173249645428060161

https://www.washingtonpost.com/video/politics/im-as-american-as-everyone-else-is-rep-omar-fires-back-at-critics-during-colbert-appearance/2019/04/11/b7032fe6-c09c-4dff-bbf3-18199cd4a0b4_video.html

2. Ilhan says its sad some Muslims celebrate Christmas:

In a tweet in 2013, Ilhan said :

"@lomonur @somalistyle I actually met (sadly) some Muslims that do  celebrate Christmas"

https://archive.is/juWUe

3. Ilhan denies affair with Tim Mynett who she later married:

Aug 2019 : In an interview, Omar denied that she is separated or dating outside her marriage.

Tim Mynett, who has become one of Omar’s closest aides, is a longtime political operative who has worked for several current and past congressional Democrats.

Note the above because this is relevant to the next point.

https://www.startribune.com/dc-doctor-alleges-her-husband-left-her-for-rep-ilhan-omar/558480212/

.Question arose because Tim Mynett’s wife alleged he was having an affair with Ilhan during their divorce proceedings

Mar 2020 : U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota has married a political consultant who worked for her, months after the two were accused of having an affair, which she denied.

A marriage license filed in Washington, D.C., shows Omar married political consultant Tim Mynett on Wednesday.

https://apnews.com/article/c1a31dbcc7adcf48667f799403873406

4. Unprecedented amount of money (900,000$) transferred to her husband's company E-Street for campaign work :

In forms filed with the Federal Election Commission (FEC) on Monday, Omar reported that another $228,111 was paid to the E Street group, owned by Tim Mynett who she married in March after denying for months that the two were having an affair.

Omar’s second quarter spending was $686,271, meaning Mynett’s firm raked in a third of the total. Although it is not illegal for members of Congress to employ relatives on their campaign, the scale of Mynett’s compensation from the Omar campaign is unprecedented.

In a Complaint to the Federal Election Commission (FEC) on August 28, 2019, NLPC alleged that Omar made personal use of campaign funds by reimbursing Mynett’s expenses while he traveled around the country with her.

https://nlpc.org/2020/07/15/rep-ilhan-omar-milks-her-own-campaign-fund/

5. Ilhan praises Hormuud Telcommunications, company in Somalia long known to be financing terrorist group Al Shabab:

In Aug 2019,

"Somali government and peacekeeping forces, need to protect @Hormuud and the Somali telecom industry as they make enormous contribution to the economy and provide vital services. 

During my visit to Somalia in 2011, I was surprised by the quick evolution of technology in Somalia."

https://twitter.com/ilhanmn/status/1165688109176172544?lang=en

From a UN report in 2012,

Jim’ale also controls Hormuud Telecommunications (“Hormuud”).  Hormuud Telecommunications is a company identified as being one of the single largest financiers of Al-Shabaab, which includes large lump-sum payments to Al-Shabaab in the hundreds of thousands of dollars and these payments to Al-Shabaab were facilitated by Jim’ale.

Ali Ahmed Nur Jim’ale (Jim’ale) has served in leadership roles with the former Somali Council of Islamic Courts, also known as the Somali Islamic Courts Union, which was a radical-Islamist element.  The most radical elements of the Somali Islamic Courts Union eventually formed the group known as Al-Shabaab.

In addition to providing funding, Hormuud Telecommunications has provided key material and logistical support to Al-Shabaab to include weapons, private fighters and ammunition.  Spokespersons for moderate Somali groups have warned the Somali people not to use Hormuud Telecommunications Company, because Hormuud personnel listen in on conversations for Al-Shabaab.  Additionally, Hormuud has cut off telephone service during Al-Shabaab attacks against pro-Somali Government forces.

https://www.un.org/press/en/2012/sc10545.doc.htm

This report came out several years ago, in 2012. One would expect Ilhan, a Representative and a member of the Foreign Affairs Committee, to be aware of what is going on in her country of birth, Somalia. So why did she praise Hormud ? I am not aware of anyone asking her about this statement of hers.

6.  Ilhan voted present on the Armenian genocide recongition resolution :

https://clerk.house.gov/Votes/2019591

Her explaination was this : 

"I also believe accountability for human rights violations — especially ethnic cleansing and genocide — is paramount. But accountability and recognition of genocide should not be used as cudgel in a political fight," Omar said.

"A true acknowledgment of historical crimes against humanity must include both the heinous genocides of the 20th century, along with earlier mass slaughters like the transatlantic slave trade and Native American genocide, which took the lives of hundreds of millions of indigenous people in this country," she added.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2019/10/30/ilhan-omar-criticized-present-vote-armenian-genocide-resolution/4100304002/

The explanation just doesn't cut it in any way. Falls away at the slightest scrutiny. ,Just vote yes for the Armenian genocide recongition resolution and introduce another legislation for the other crimes against humanity. Why do you have to vote present for this ? Ilhan got significant flak for the present vote on this resolution, including from progressives and rightfully so.

7. Voted no to sanctions on Turkey military and political leaders connected to invasion of Syria:

Ilhan voted no on this bill that specifically put sanctions on Turkey military, leaders, state instituitions if they were found backing invasion of Syria in late 2019 : 

H.R.4695 - PACT Act

https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/4695

Her statement in an op-ed was this :

"Research has shown that sanctions rarely achieve their desired goals. In the worst-case scenario, they hurt the people of a country — generally the very people we’re purporting to help — without making a dent in the country’s behavior. And in the case of human rights abusers, research suggests that more abuses typically occur with economic sanctions in place than without them."

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/ilhan-omar-sanctions-are-part-of-a-failed-foreign-policy-playbook-stop-relying-on-them/2019/10/23/b7cbb1ca-f510-11e9-a285-882a8e386a96_story.html

This is a legitimate criticism of general economic sanctions from US, which is a big chunk of US sanctions. But this legislation was not a general economic sanctions bill. This was a sanctions bill specifically targetted to those supporting Syria invasion - military, political leaders, state instituitions. So what she said doesn't apply here. These are not the kind of sanctions that have hurt common people in Venezuela, Iran, Syria etc. These sanctions were to deter Turkey high level interests from the invasion of Syria and did not involve common people.

Here is Ilhan doubling down with respect to her misdirection on the Turkey sanctions bill :

"First you were ok to green light it, and now want to dive into an economic war with Turkey by imposing crippling sanctions them?

Was this the strategy all along or were you just too incompetent to talk  it through with him on that phone call? 

https://twitter.com/IlhanMN/status/1183483753450086401

"Not all sanctions are alike, some sanction economically devastate a country and ultimately only harm its citizens, I am never for those."

https://twitter.com/IlhanMN/status/1183492217098395648

I repeat : The sanctions with respect to Turkey were not targetting common people at all. This was a sanctions bill specifically targetted to those supporting Syria invasion - military, political leaders, state instituitions.

8. Ilhan Omar and Turkey : 

As pointed out above, Ilhan :

a. voted present on the Armenian genocide resolution giving a weak explanation. 

b.She gave a convincingly misleading explanation for voting against sanctions targetted to Turkey military&political institutions. Before coming under real fire for the above 2, not once had she spoken out or taken any legislative action against Erdogan for wrongdoing.

c. Ilhan did not condemn Turkey's invasion of Syria.

After taking fire for the 2 votes, she has done these :

a. Pushes Turkey on Kurdish Prisoners

b. Co-signed letter to senior State Department official Amb. James Jeffrey, demanding an investigation into Turkey’s alleged use of chemical weapons during its invasion of Syria.

c. Wrote a social media post commemorating the Armenian Genocide on April 24, the international Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day. But she has not apologized for her preset vote on the genocide resolution.

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/skeptics/ilhan-omar-pushes-turkey-kurdish-prisoners-155916

But to be noted that, Ilhan:

Has still not openly criticized Erdogan - not on invasion of Syria, not on his statements on re-establishment on caliphate etc.


So were the 3 efforts above only for damage control after significant backlash? Smaller stuff , but ignoring the real big ones ?

Some have conjectured that the unwillingness to go after Erdogan is because of Erdogan's ties with Somalia.

9. Takes 14K from Nancy Pelosi PACs and flaunts Pelosi's endorsement of her:  :

"In this House, we fight #ForThePeople!"

Pic has : Endorsed by Rep. Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the House ....

https://twitter.com/ilhanmn/status/1292478401207504898?lang=en

She could have stayed silent or just said thank you (if she wanted to be gracious), but to flaunt the endorsement ? really ?

"New FEC filing today shows Ilhan Omar's campaign received $4,000 from Nancy Pelosi's campaign, as well as $10,000 from PAC To The Future—which draws the bulk of it's funding from Pelosi's billionaire funded Victory Fund, on top of corporations like Goldman Sachs and Boeing."

https://twitter.com/RobletoFire/status/1288893902188142593

https://www.opensecrets.org/members-of-congress/ilhan-omar/contributors?cid=N00043581&cycle=2020&recs=100&type=C

Ilhan has the support of the establishment. There's nothing adversarial here – just drama at times to pretend otherwise.

10. Ilhan spreads blatantly false propaganda about India's governing party - Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP):

Kashmir is part of an overall Hindu nationalism project, says Rep. Ilhan Omar

https://www.indiaabroad.com/us_affairs/kashmir-is-part-of-an-overall-hindu-nationalism-project-says-rep-ilhan-omar/article_049ee7ac-f849-11e9-9e78-b3905e179f62.html

The BJP has abolished the horrible triple talaq that was used to abuse so many Muslim women.has given and is giving millions of scholarships to Muslims, is funding madrasass+modernizing them by connecting them to mainstream education.

https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/muslim-women-thank-pm-modi-on-passage-of-triple-talaq-bill/articleshow/70465902.cms?from=mdr

https://theprint.in/india/more-muslims-govt-scholarships-modi-govt-congress-upa/308154//

https://www.business-standard.com/article/news-ani/muslim-clerics-hail-centre-s-decision-to-connect-madrasas-to-mainstream-education-119061200086_1.html

And no, Modi was not complicit or negligent in the Gujarat riots. The government at the center at that time was head by Indian National Congress, very hostile to Modi. The investigation was under them for several years and Modi was cleared by a neutral Supreme Court of any negligence or complicity.

"Law and order review meetings were held by Modi and all the things was done to control the situation... the Army was called on time to contain the communal violence."

https://www.news18.com/news/india/how-sit-report-exonerates-modi-the-highlights-473243.html

The Delhi riots which was accused of being an anti-Muslim pogrom in a big chunk of MSM was actually masterminded by Tahir Hussain, a Muslim politician, who wanted to teach Hindus a lesson. Tons of evidence was found at his place months ago and Tahir Hussain confessed to his role in masterminding the riots, along with Khalid Saifi and PFI member Danish.

https://zeenews.india.com/india/tahir-hussain-confesses-masterminding-delhi-riots-with-ex-jnu-student-umar-khalid-khalid-saifi-says-wanted-to-teach-lesson-to-hindus-2300190.html

For more details about Modi/BJP, you can check these 2 articles :

Clearing the misconceptions/propaganda against Modi and some actual valid criticisms

https://abhijitmkthoughts.blogspot.com/2020/03/clearing-misconceptionspropaganda.html

Achievements of Modi government

https://abhijitmkthoughts.blogspot.com/2020/08/achievements-of-modi-government.html

11. Ilhan in order to further her agenda accuses a neutral journalist Aarti Tikoo Singh of being a mouthpiece of BJP:

Aarti Tikoo Singh is an Indian journalist, who also is a Kashmiri Pandit. The Kashmiri Pandits were ethnically cleansed from the Kashmir valley in the early 90s.

Aarti mentioned facts about Islamist terrorism being a big problem in Kashmir killing Kashmiri Muslims and Hindus. She and her family themselves were victims of this having been forced out of Kashmir valley due to Islamist terrorism sponsored/helped by Pakistan. She also mentioned facts about removal of Article 370 helping people - facts. 

She has written articles both praising and criticizing the Bharitya Janata Party (BJP).

She was also the only one in the hearing to be on the ground reporting from Kashmir in that timeframe.For stating facts in the hearing that BJP has also mentioned, Ilhan accused Aarti Tikoo of being a mouthpiece of the government. Never mind that Aarti has criticized and continues to criticize BJP whenever she thinks BJP is doing something wrong. See the next point as well.

https://punemirror.indiatimes.com/news/india/indian-scribes-face-off-with-us-congresswoman/articleshow/71728616.cms

Aarti Tikoo "My record, my professional record is that I have lashed out at every single government in India on various issues, from human rights violations committed in Kashmir to the lynchings over beef. I have a record of being non-partisan throughout in my profession of the last 20 years. So for Ms Omar to say... such accusations against me, is really condemnable."

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/us-hearing-on-kashmir-a-setup-against-india-in-favour-of-pakistan-says-journalist-aarti-tikoo-singh-2121204

12. Not once condemning Pakistan govt/army sponsored terrorism or human rights abuses there

Not once has Ilhan condemned terrorism sponsored/helped by Pakistan. I checked both her twitter accounts. Nothing. I checked on google. Nothing.

Ilhan:

"In your version of the story, the only problems in Kashmir are caused by what you call militants, the only people protesting to break away from India; and are all nefariously backed by Pak."

what you call militants ? hmm, they aren't militants ? really? 

Pakistan govt/army doesn't back terrorism in Kashmir ? 

Osama bin Laden was found hiding in Pakistan close to the capital Islamabad. Current Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan himself has said that Pakistan army/govts in the past had backed terrorism.

“Until we came to power, the governments did not have the political will. When you talk about militant groups, they still have about 30,000-40,000 armed people who have been trained and fought in some part of Afghanistan or maybe Kashmir,” Khan said

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/pakistan/imran-khan-admits-pakistans-role-in-kashmir-terrorism/articleshow/70367213.cms

That Pakistan govt/army sponsors terrorism in Kashmir and Afghanistan is a well known fact. Its why it is in the FATF grey list.

Minorities (Hindus, Sikhs, Christians, athiests etc.) are mistreated badly in Pakistan from killings to forced conversions to other atrocities. Blasphemy laws are really harsh.Those accused of blasphemy are treated harshly.

But Ilhan, the self-proclaimed champion of human rights, has nothing to say on these two fronts, while she happily spreads false propaganda about India and BJP. And has the gall to say "what you call militants".

13. Co-sponsored New Way Forward Act that would increase illegal immigration:

Ilhan Co-Sponsored this bill - New Way Forward Act - which decriminalizes border crossing (would which inevitably increase illegal migration) instead of just focussing on humane treatment of those illegally crossing (there were 2 legislations in early 2019 for this).

There are a couple of decent measures in the bill, but it would inevitably lead to more illegal immigration and overall its a significant negative.



One of the bills to ensure humane treatment of illegal immigrants.
H.R.541 - Keep Families Together Act


This ensures humane treatment of the people caught illegally crossing the border and their families.

The argument for decriminalization was the bad treatment of illegal immigrants. The solution is not to decriminalize border crossing (which leads to less discouragement of those illegally crossing, thus inevitably increasing illegal immigration), but to ensure humane treatment of those illegal immigrants which HR 541 does. 

Why the push for decriminalization then ? Hmm, could it have something do with this ?

Meanwhile Hillary Clinton :

*Hillary Clinton Said Her Dream Is A Hemispheric Common Market, With Open Trade And Open Markets. *“My dream is a hemispheric common market, with open trade and open borders, some time in the future with energy that is as green and sustainable as we can get it, powering growth and opportunity for every person in the hemisphere.” [05162013 Remarks to Banco Itau.doc, p.28]


The New Way Forward Act doesn't obviously advocate for open borders directly (that would be dumb), but does move towards that slowly. It doesn't prove any link with what Hillary wants, but one needs to keep his/her eyes open.

14. Wrongly painting majority of Syria as wanting Assad out and not talking about US interference there

"The people of Syria revolted against Assad's repressive dictatorship 8 years ago today, demanding a more just and free government. Peace loving people around the world stand in solidarity with them in this struggle!"

https://twitter.com/ilhan/status/1106729645003685888?lang=en

Assad is a dictator. Some Syrian people did and do want him out, but not a majority. Majority see alternatives as worse or far worse.

In 2013 : NATO has been studying data that told of a sharp rise in support for Assad. The data, compiled by Western-sponsored activists and organizations,showed that a majority of Syrians were alarmed by the Al Qaida takeover of the Sunni revolt and preferred to return to Assad, Middle East Newsline reported.

The data, relayed to NATO over the last month, asserted that 70 percent of Syrians support the Assad regime. Another 20 percent were deemed neutral and the remaining 10 percent expressed support for the rebels.

https://www.worldtribune.com/archives/greatest-hits-2013-nato-data-assad-winning-the-war-for-syrians-hearts-and-minds/

I checked. Ilhan has not once opposed US regime change efforts in Syria through arming moderate rebels. She has not once talked about US arming Al Qaeda affiliates indirectly in Syria to topple Assad. She has not once opposed general economic sanctions on Syria, while she opposed them on Iran, Venezuela. Why not oppose them on Syria as well, Ilhan ? Double standards much ?

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/ilhan-omar-sanctions-are-part-of-a-failed-foreign-policy-playbook-stop-relying-on-them/2019/10/23/b7cbb1ca-f510-11e9-a285-882a8e386a96_story.html

15. Offensive/misguided statements about Israel/Jewish people :

Omar has been under scrutiny for a 2012 tweet amid the Israeli conflict with Hamas in Gaza, in which she wrote: “Israel has hypnotized the world, may Allah awaken the people and help them see the evil doings of Israel. #Gaza #Palestine #Israel.”

Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) expressed regret for saying in a 2012 tweet that “Israel has hypnotized the world” while doing “evil,” saying she had not realized her words would be offensive to Jewish people.

https://thehill.com/homenews/house/426425-rep-omar-apologizes-for-tweet-about-israel

For why it is offensive, read this :

Ilhan Omar and the Myth of Jewish Hypnosis

A conspiracy theory with ancient roots and a bloody history.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/21/opinion/ilhan-omar-israel-jews.html

Now moving on to 2019 :

“It’s all about the Benjamins, baby,” Omar responded, a reference to Benjamin Franklin, whose face is on the $100 bill.

That tweet generated a response from a Jewish journalist who asked Omar who she believed was “paying American politicians to be pro-Israel”. The congresswoman replied: “AIPAC,”

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/feb/11/ilhan-omar-antisemitic-tweets-house-democrats-apology

AIPAC does have quite a bit of influence in US including monied interests. But to put it that crassly and generalize the way she did is problematic which is why she again apologized.

“To resort to age-old stereotypes about Jews using money to buy influence is terrible, particularly in the year 2019 we should all know better,” said Steve Hunegs, the executive director of the JCRC said,

https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2019/02/11/ilhan-omar-twitter-anti-semitism-aipac-its-all-about-the-benjamins/

16. Voted no on resolution regarding United States efforts to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through a negotiated two-state solution

This resolution expresses the sense of the House of Representatives that only a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict can ensure Israel's survival as a secure Jewish and democratic state and fulfill the legitimate aspirations for a Palestinian state. It also expresses the sense that any U.S. proposal to achieve a just, stable, and lasting solution should expressly endorse a two-state solution and discourage steps that would put a peaceful resolution further out of reach.

https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-resolution/326

17. Ilhan lied that Trump was talking about Kurdish people being cleaned out when he was talking about terrorists being cleaned out :

-Then said the Kurdish people had to be “cleaned out.”

https://twitter.com/IlhanMN/status/1185244621103874048

Trump:

"Turkey in all fairness, they have had a legitimate problem with terrorists. They had a lot of people in there that they couldn't have. They have suffered a lot of loss of lives also. And they had to have it cleaned out"

In the same video, after a few seconds

"During those five days, the Kurds and the other people they are going to be taken great care of"

Trump never said Kurdish people had to be cleaned out.

Ilhan blatantly lied here.

Yeah, Trump has said Islamophobic stuff about Ilhan and that deserves serious condemnation. Does it mean you justify Ilhan blatantly lying like this ? Nope.

18. Cozying upto Hillary Clinton and tacit support : 

Ilhan in late 2018, was excited to find Hillary's mail 

"We were a little late getting through all the mail, but this one from 

@HillaryClinton

 was pretty exciting to find in the stack.

💙💙💙"

https://twitter.com/IlhanMN/status/1077341817853628416

Its fine  to say thank you to anyone who wishes you, but to be fangirlish like this ?

Hillary Clinton came out with a wild baseless accusation that Tulsi was a Russian agent. Tulsi hit back saying Hillary was the queen of warmongers, embodiment of corruption, and personification of the rot that has sickened the Democratic Party.

Ilhan's response was to post a gif expressing shock/surprise. She did not defend Tulsi against Hillary's baseless smear.

And of course it gets worse.

A couple of days after Tulsi's statement. 

Mehdi Hasan interviewed Ilhan : 

Mehdi: "Tulsi or Hillary?"

Ilhan: "Neither"

Mehdi: "That's the right answer, that's the right answer!"

https://twitter.com/saltdeezy/status/1313626321000394752

Keep in mind, Tulsi had defended Ilhan atleast thrice before - twice against Islamaphobia, once against allegation of anti-Semitism.

"We must stand united to condemn religious bigotry. The anti-Muslim bigotry and hate expressed towards Rep. Ilhan Omar comparing her to 9/11 terrorists is reprehensible."

https://twitter.com/tulsigabbard/status/1102193911034990592?lang=en

"I don't believe her intent was to cause any offense to anyone" - Tulsi on allegations of anti-Semitism against Ilhan :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9JwdR8B-6g&ab_channel=TheDamageReport


"Trump is shamelessly trying to foment religious bigotry against ⁦#IlhanOmar & all Muslims, based on the horrendous actions of a few individuals claiming to be Muslim. This is the very definition of religious bigotry & Trump is fomenting it for political gain. Dangerous & sad"

followed by a video :

https://twitter.com/TulsiGabbard/status/1117503224271884288

19. Ilhan voted no on a bill denying payout to beneficiaries if the insured’s death occurred directly or indirectly as a result of the insured’s furtherance of terrorism

Voting records show that as a state representative, Omar was one of two members to vote against H.F. 1397, a 2017 bill that sought to allow life insurance companies the ability to deny payouts to beneficiaries “if the insured’s death occurs directly or indirectly as a result of the insured’s furtherance of terrorism.”

The Minnesota bill passed the House in a 127-2 vote. Omar and fellow state Rep. John Lesch were the only members to vote against the bill. Lesch voiced concern that the wording of the bill might give insurance companies too much discretion over what constitutes terrorism.

“[The bill] allows an insurance company, not a court, to decide what constitutes an act of terrorism under the cited statute, and it lowers the burden on that call to preponderance of the evidence,” Lesch told Alpha News, a Minnesota-based news outlet.

He expressed that he was not opposed to the idea behind the bill: “Terrorists should not be able to send life insurance benefits to beneficiaries based on bad faith recent policy purchases. I think we can all agree on that.”

It’s unclear why Omar voted against the bill. Her office did not respond to a request for comment.

https://checkyourfact.com/2019/03/18/fact-check-ilhan-omar-vote-no-bill-block-insurance-payments-families-terrorists/

The original article reporting this in 2017 : https://alphanewsmn.com/omar-lesch-no-votes-ending-terrorist-life-insurance-payouts/

The vote : https://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/votes/votes.asp?ls_year=90&billnum=HF1397&session_number=0&year=2017&id=185

The text of the legislation : https://www.revisor.mn.gov/bills/text.php?session=ls90&number=HF1397&session_number=0&session_year=2017&version=list

I have not found any explanation from Ilhan on this vote anywhere on the net.

20. Ilhan and CAIR

From Ilhan's some people did something speech:

"CAIR was founded after 9/11 because they recognized that some people did something and that all of us were starting to lose access to our civil liberties. ".....

https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/apr/15/ilhan-omar/ilhan-omar-misstates-facts-about-cairs-founding/

CAIR (Council on American–Islamic Relations) was founded in June 1994.

https://ca.cair.com/about-us/history/

We asked Omar’s staff why she made such a clear mistake about an organization that she says she supports. Spokesperson Jeremy Slevin said that CAIR had doubled in size after the Sept. 11 attacks. "It was a misstatement, and she now knows that it was founded earlier," he said.

https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2019/apr/15/ilhan-omar/ilhan-omar-misstates-facts-about-cairs-founding/

Notice that the speech of hers was at a CAIR organised event :

Rep. Ilhan Omar slammed for 9/11 remark at CAIR event: 'Some people did something'

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/apr/10/ilhan-omar-slammed-911-remark-cair-event-some-peop/

How could Ilhan commit such a mistake ?

Doubling in size has nothing to do with founding of CAIR. Her speech was based on the premise that "CAIR was founded after 9/11 because they recognized that some people did something and that all of us were starting to lose access to our civil liberties"

So how could there not be a simple check from her or her staff ? She and her staff are not that utterly incompetent right ?

What's an another explanation ? Trying to gain more sympathy by saying CAIR founded because of increase in Islamaphobia after 9/11 in US (its true Islamophobia increased in US after 9/11, but to utter a falsehood like this about founding of CAIR ?). Just 

Ilhan has publicly openly talked about support of CAIR multiple times.

Now lets go on to more about problems with CAIR :

The link describing in detail is here : 

CAIR (Council on American–Islamic Relations) exposed:

https://abhijitmkthoughts.blogspot.com/2020/10/cair-council-on-americanislamic.html

I am just going to summarize here : 

a. Chris Gaubatz's undercover operation on CAIR : This exposed immigration fraud by one of their attorneys, discussion of co-ordination with Bin Laden&associates; conspiracy to influence Congress, specifically judiciary, intelligence, and homeland security committees ; ordering books from the Saudi embassy on the virtue of jihad and martyrdom; working with a Muslim law enforcement officer to influence a major terrorism investigation by accessing a classified federal police database and tipping off the suspect.

b. Terrorism/money laundering convictions and CAIR's responses : Randall "Ismail" Royer, Ghassan Elashi, Abdurahman Alamoudi, Muthanna Al-Hanooti - Members of CAIR who have been convicted with respect to terrorism or money laundering charges. 

Of course CAIR cannot be responsible for the independent actions of its officials or affiliated members. But it is to be noted that in the above mentioned cases, CAIR has either obfuscated or been silent on these or talked about about sentences being unfair precisely because they are Muslim or Arab. 

Also in the interest of completeness, CAIR has correctly corrected the record on 2 other names frequently brought up : Baseem Khalfagi and Rabih Hadad, neither of whom were CAIR employees.

c. Nihad Awad, co-founder and and Executive Director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), announced his support for Hamas in 1994. There has been further obfuscation from Awad/CAIR on this which is covered in the CAIR article. This is even with Awad denouncing Hamas in 2006.

d. In 2009, a Federal Judge handed down sentences in Holy Land Foundation (HLF) case, in which CAIR was listed as unindicted co-conspirator. Five former leaders of a HLF were convicted of funneling more than $12 million to the Palestinian terrorist group Hamas. A federal judge said government introduced extensive evidence tying CAIR to Hamas. FBI cut Ties With CAIR following this terror financing trial of HLF.

e. CAIR was designated as terrorist group by UAE in 2014 :  UAE foreign minister when asked about it: "Our threshold is quite low when we talk about extremism. We cannot accept incitement or funding when we look at some of these organisations. For many countries, the definition of terror is that you have to carry a weapon and terrorise people. For us, it’s much beyond that; we cannot tolerate even the smallest, tiniest amount of terrorism"


Some smears which are false :

1. Picture of someone looking like Ilhan in a military uniform holding a gun. That was from 1978, 4 years before Ilhan was born, people.

https://apnews.com/article/6978680630

2. False claim that she voted against anti-FGM (female genital mutilation) bill as a representative of Minnesota state. Comes from misleading article in Star Tribune. She voted for the anti-FGM bill.

https://checkyourfact.com/2018/11/29/fact-check-ilhan-omar-vote-female-genital-mutilation-felony/

https://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/votes/votes.asp?ls_year=90&billnum=HF2621&session_number=0&year=2017&id=285

3. Claim that Ilhan Omar voted against sending aid to Somalia:

This was a part of 2 big bills containing many things. Ilhan obviously wanted aid for Somalia, but was against some of the other things in the bills.So she voted against the bills.

https://www.somalispot.com/threads/ilhan-omar-voted-against-the-debt-relief-for-somalia.71413/

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sita Ramam movie review

Tulsi Gabbard is amazing on domestic issues part2

Using a rope to square a circle - Śulba Sūtras